Sunday 23 December 2012

Review: Crewel

Title: Crewel (Crewel World #1)
Author: Gennifer Albin
Publisher: Faber & Faber
Released: 16th October 2012
Rating: 4 of 5 stars

Crewel is a book that stunned me with its originality and creativity; it looked at all the repetitive ideas out there, smirked and threw itself in the faces of weary readers.  The proverbial box is just a speck in the distance when it comes to Albin's imagination, something which I have no doubt many of us are grateful for.

In opening the book we find ourselves in Arras, a world where women called Spinsters are able to manipulate the very threads of the universe.  They can literally see time and influence the appearance of the world around us; they have the ability to both bring life and take it away, all done by a swift move of the hand.  Adelice is one such Spinster.  Having so far successfully managed to keep anyone outside of her parents from finding out, one accident brings the Guild come banging on the door to collect her.  Whisked away in a whirlwind of fear and uncertainty, Adelice soon realises that things are far more complex than they first seemed and her own reality far more sinister.

Trying to imagine Arras is not an easy task.  Albin presents to us this idea of there being threads that make up time and space and matter, and trying to picture this in your head can get very confusing.  Nevertheless, if you can picture something even approaching this concept, you find yourself stunned at how brilliant it is. We see three different perspectives of the world, pyhsically speaking: the first is basic, like looking at your room or a photo, nothing more. The second is through the eyes of a Spinster, seeing the different strands and colours blending to create shapes and forms, weaving themselves together as if to create a three-dimensional tapestry.  The third comes with the astounding plot twist.  Albin builds this world gradually so that it really is as if the reader is right there with Adelice, learning and seeing more about it.  The layers there are to Arras are truly astounding.

Adelice herself is a character easy to sympathise with.  The opening of the book sees her suffer greatly, and she has to deal with that all the way through.  She questions, challenges, thinks - in short, she is not a weak character.  Of course she forgets sometimes what kind of a world she's actually living in, and so makes mistakes; but these make her a realistic character, and are never infuriating.  This development is consistent across the characters, and each of these, too, are composed of layers.  Patton in particular is a good example of how views of right and wrong here are convoluted, and also how you can never really be sure who to trust.  The uncertainty I felt towards him kept me curious, making me doubly determined to keep reading; the conversations between him and Adelice also had me laughing.  Our protagonist is definitely one for humour, a quality I found very appreciable.

Of course there had to be something to mar an otherwise excellent read, and in this case it's the ever-present love triangle.  Unfortunately I felt the romance here let the book down.  There was something rather obvious staring Adelice in the face which she failed to notice until the end, and neither of the love interests, namely Erik and Jost, succeeded in tearing my heart in two or even forcing me to take a side.  Even now I couldn't really tell you who I prefer more.  In any case, it still wasn't that bad and Albin did manage to write it well.  There is a lot of scope for development in the case of Adelice's relationship, and reading about the love triangle was still entertaining.

The ending completely blew me away.  It is, without a doubt, the perfect opening for a sequel, and to say that it was unpredictable is an understatement.  I am very much excited to see where the author goes with this and I honestly can't wait to read the next one.  Enthralling, original and wonderfully complex, Crewel is an absolute must-read.


  1. I find the different possibilities with weaving time might confuse me. I passes on this one because of that. It does sound like an intriguing read, Aa'Ishah, and your review is wonderful. :)

  2. I'm glad you enjoyed Crewel Aa'Ishah, I had really high hopes for this one, but it sort of fell flat for me, I wasn't even able to finish the book! I hope you enjoy the sequel just as much! Brilliant review! :)

  3. The way you described about threads and strands making up time, space and matter reminds me of a clairvoyant training course that I took. I think I'll like the story. There are just so many awesome books being released that I sort of forgot about this one. Awesome review, Aa'Ishah!

  4. Originality and creativity, I keep seeing both of these words in every review I've seen of this book. I'm really curious now to see how the world here was made. It seems very fascinating. Brilliant review, A. :)

  5. Amazing review - you've fully persuaded me to go out and get this book now! Up 'till now I've not really been that intrigued by it but now that I have, I can't believe I didn't get it sooner! I love authors that can create whole new, creative, unusual worlds that a reader can easily get swept up in and the main character sounds like a fairly likeable one too! It's a pity the romance fell a bit flat for you though - I, personally, both love and hate love triangles! :3 Thanks for sharing this very convincing review! :) New follower also!

    I'd love for you to stop by my YA book blog, Booktastic Reviews, if you get the chance. :) xx

  6. This is the second glowing review I've read of this in the past five minutes, Aa'Ishah. :) The love-triangle is a bit disappointing, but I know I'll be able to forgive that aspect in light of the supposed creativity and originality of this! Fabulous review, darling. :)

  7. I'm so glad you enjoyed this one, Aa'Ishah! I wasn't a huge fan of it, mostly because of the love triangle and the MC, but I'm thrilled you loved this as it truly does have SO much to love. Amazing review! :)


Hello! Please feel free to leave a comment, I love hearing from you all! I read every one and do my best to visit your blog in return. I look forward to hearing your thoughts! :)

Please note that this blog is now an award-free zone. I appreciate the thought, but unfortunately I just don't have the time anymore.